Superchargers & Turbo chargers
We will attempt to
help you better understand the
differences between a positive
displacement blower vs centrifugal
superchargers & the difference
between a blower vs a turbo.
Supercharger
(also known as a blower) is
an air compressor used to force more
air (and hence more oxygen) into the
combustion chambers of an internal
combustion engine than can be
achieved with ambient conditions or
atmospheric pressure. They are
general powered mechanically by
belt, gear, or chain-drive from the
engine's crankshaft.
Turbo chargers
do
the same thing that a supercharger
does but they are driven off of the
exhaust gases of the engine rather
than the crankshaft.
So what is the
principle difference behind a
positive displacement blower & a
centrifugal: The manor in which they
produce boost?
Any supercharger is
belt driven off of your motors
crankshaft, so its driven speed is
directly connected to engine speed.
If you double the engine speed the
superchargers driven speed doubles.
The amount of airflow
a centrifugal blower delivers
increases roughly at a square of its
driven speed, it is NOT linear. This
means that the airflow of the blower
will increase faster then what the
engines airflow requires, meaning
that the boost level will increase
with an increase in RPM. As a
result you should set the blower so
that its max boost occurs at
redline.
Now a positive
displacement blower produces airflow
in a totally different way. For
each RPM the amount of airflow it
pumps is fixed where as centrifugal
will vary depending on variables.
With the boost level of a positive
displacement supercharger being
fixed it will deliver airflow
linearly so it will generally
achieve fully boost around 2,500 RPM
& maintain full boost throughout the
rpm band.
If you take a
centrifugal blower and a positive
displacement blower and set them to
have the same max boost then dyno
them you will find their peak HP
will probably be pretty similar but
the power & torque under the curve
will be higher on the positive
displacement blower. When driving
them the centrifugally supercharged
cars power will start to feel
considerably stronger as the RPM
rises where the positive
displacement supercharged car is
going to feel like a much larger
engine.
Centrifugal blowers
are popular in the aftermarket
street market because they are
physically smaller in size and are
much easier to fit under the hood
where as a positive displacement
blower will generally require an
aftermarket hood.
A major thing to
keep in mind when trying to decide
between a positive displacement
blower vs an centrifugal blower is
this, do not over power the cars
chassis especially at lower RPM’s.
One of the advantages in a
centrifugal supercharger on a street
car is the fact that you can control
the boost level based on RPM. This
means that you can increase boost
(power) as the cars speed increases
which helps control traction. Now if
a car was to have NO traction issues
which we all know is almost
impossible on a street car then you
would want all your boost instantly
(positive displacement blower).
Where we generally see better
results on a street vehicle using a
positive displacement type blower
over a centrifugal is on a heavy
sport utility vehicle or SUV. These
type vehicles generally are very
heavy & have lower operating RPM’s
so it is generally better to get max
boost by 2500rpm because traction is
not as much of an issue.
How does a blower
make such huge power gains? A
blower compresses air into the
cylinder at a rate which is greater
than what the motor alone could
achieve. By forcing larger amounts
of air into the cylinder it is
putting more oxygen into the
cylinder. If one was to break down
horsepower to its most basic element
it would be OXYGEN. One
would then ask why not inject pure
oxygen into the motor for optimum
power? Pure oxygen is unstable and
the burn rate cannot be controlled.
Look at nitrous oxide (N2O), this
stands for 2 particles of nitrogen &
one particle of oxygen. The 2
nitrogen molecules help stabilize
the burn rate of the oxygen molecule
as well as keep it cool so that it
will stay as an oxygen molecule.
When the air is being
compressed it heats up, based on how
efficient the blower/turbo is will
determine the horse power gain per
pound of boost, this is referred to
as volumetric efficiency. Say we
have to blowers on identical motors
making the exact same amount of
boost. Blower one increases the air
temperature from an ambient of 100
to 120 degrees at redline where as
the 2nd blower increases
the temperature to lets say 160
degrees. Blower one (better
efficiency) will end up making more
power because as air temperature
increases the oxygen content
decreases and we know that oxygen is
what makes the power. Now lets say
that we have a motor making 10 psi
and we want to increase the boost to
14psi, in theory the car should make
more horse power due to the increase
in boost but this is not necessarily
true. This is where volumetric
efficiency becomes critical. If the
blower was operating at peak
efficiency already and you increase
the blowers operating RPM you then
end up pushing it outside of its
optimum efficiency range which means
the air temperature will drastically
increase. This increase in air
temperature will reduce the oxygen
content of the air in turn producing
less horse power per pound of
boost. Here is an example: Motor is
producing 10psi @ 20 hp per pound of
boost 10x20=200 horse power gain.
You then up the boost to 14psi but
due to the efficiency drop you are
only able to generate 15 hp per
pound of boost (14x15=210hp),
210-200=10 so your net gain is
ONLY 10HP. You have now put the
motor under allot more stress which
means you are more likely to hurt
the motor for a measly 10hp. This
is why it is critical that you
choose the right blower for your
application.
|